Exosomes isolation methods
It is critical to understand the importance of exosome isolation methods, which play key roles in cell-to-cell communication and disease mechanisms. Exosomes are tiny vesicles released by cells that contain biomolecules such as proteins and sequences that can affect the functions of surrounding cells. By understanding how exosomes are isolated, we can study the mechanism of cell-to-cell message transmission, thereby revealing the occurrence and development of many diseases.
The study of exosomes is not only of great significance to basic science, but also expected. Therefore, an in-depth understanding of exosome isolation methods will not only help reveal the mysteries of life, but also has the potential to promote innovation and progress in the medical field.
What are exosomes/extracellular vesicles?
Nomenclature and biological origin of extracellular vesicles
Methods and differences in isolating exosomes
Conventional ultrafiltration VS tangential flow filtration (TFF)
Applications of exosomes
What are exosomes/extracellular vesicles?
It is worth noting that since the biological origin of various vesicles is difficult to clearly identify, the International Society for Extracellular Vesicles (ISEV) recommended in the MISEV2018 guideline that they be named in the following way:
Nomenclature and biological origin of extracellular vesicles
It is worth noting that since the biological origin of various vesicles is difficult to clearly identify, the International Society for Extracellular Vesicles (ISEV) recommended in the MISEV2018 guideline that they be named in the following way:
Naming basis |
Physical characteristics |
Surface markers; biochemical composition |
Descriptions of conditions or cell of origin |
Example |
•Exosome Size: small / medium / large extracellular vesicles (sEVs / mEVs / lEVs) •Density: slow / middle, high EVs |
•D63+ / CD81+ EVs •Annexin A5-stained EVs |
• Podocyte EVs • Hypoxic EVs • Large oncosomes • Apoptotic bodies |
What is the difference between liposomes and EVs?
Compared with synthetic carriers such as liposomes and nanoparticles, exosomes have characteristics such as endogeneity and heterogeneity, making exosomes useful as Excellent carriers can transport bioactive substances to target cells through a variety of pathways and sites to participate in regulation, such as tissue repair, Immune regulation, angiogenesis, cellular differentiation, neoplasia, etc.
Advantages and disadvantages of exosomes
Therefore, exosomes have great potential and advantages in disease diagnosis, treatment and biology research, such as as biomarkers for tumor diagnosis and drugs for cancer treatment. carrier etc. However, exosomes also have some limitations, such as low stability, low yield, low purity, and weak targeting, which may limit their clinical application.
Extracellular vesicles, EVs |
Exosomes |
Microvesicles |
Apoptotic bodies |
Size |
40~120 nm |
100~1000 nm |
1000~5000 nm |
Biogenesis |
Multivesicular bodies, MVB |
Plasma membrane, outward budding |
Plasma membrane, apoptosis process |
Exosomes isolation methods
As the research on exosomes isolation continues to deepen, their potential application value is also continuously being explored. The isolation, purification, and concentration (also known as enrichment) of exosomes are critical for evaluating their biological functions and their downstream applications. However, the components of biological samples are complex and contain many similar molecular structures, such as cell fragments, protein aggregates, lipoproteins, etc., and the size and composition of exosomes are heterogeneous, making “isolation” more challenging. Therefore, “how to effectively isolate and concentrate exosomes” is a major test faced in academic research and clinical applications.
Differences between exosomes isolation methods
There are many exosomes isolation methods, depending on the principles. Common exosomes isolation methods are ultracentrifugation, particle size screening chromatography, ultrafiltration, precipitation and immunoaffinity. The following table summarizes the differences between the methods:
|
Ultracentrifugation |
Particle size screening chromatography (SEC) |
Ultrafiltration (UF) |
Precipitation |
Immunoaffinity (IA) |
Principle |
Sedimentation Coefficient (size, density) |
Hydrodynamic Radius (size, molecular weight) |
Membrane pore size (size, molecular weight) |
Solubility (surface charge) |
Specific Binding (Membrane protein marker) |
Yield |
Low |
Medium |
High |
High |
Low |
Purity |
Medium (lipoprotein) |
Medium to high (lipoprotein, albumin) |
Medium (protein) |
Low (proteins, polymers) |
High |
Functionality |
Medium |
High |
Medium |
Low |
Low |
Time |
> 4 hr |
0.3 hr*2 |
< 4 hr |
≈0.3~12 hr |
4~20 hr |
Sample volume |
Large |
Medium |
Large *(TFF) |
Large |
Small |
Denature and inactive of EVs |
Yes (high speed) |
No |
Yes (Shear force) |
Yes (Co-precipitates with proteins or polymers) |
Yes (Refining steps) |
Complexity |
Medium |
Simple |
Simple |
Simple |
Medium |
Scalability |
Medium |
High |
Medium to high 3(TFF) |
High |
Low |
Other |
• Labor intensive and time consuming |
• High reproducibility • EVs have complete functions and forms |
• High reproducibility • High flexibility of use • Filter membrane clogged |
• Polymers are difficult to separate • More costly kit |
• EVs have the best purity • Study of specific EV subpopulations • Unable to separate total EVs • Antibodies are expensive |
*1 Ultracentrifugation (UC) is also called differential centrifugation (dUC)
*2 EVs purification can be completed within 20 minutes using commercially available kits
*3 High scalability refers to TFF tangential flow filtration method
Conventional ultrafiltration VS tangential flow filtration
Ultrafiltration (UF) is a method of separation based on molecular size, which can be subdivided into centrifugal-driven ultrafiltration centrifuge tubes, pressure-driven stirred filters, and tangential flow filtration (TFF). type. Ultrafiltration centrifugal tubes and stirred filters are easy to operate and have fast processing time, but the biggest problem is that the filter membrane is easily clogged, which not only reduces the separation efficiency but also increases the cost; and the development of tangential flow filtration technology (TFF) It can significantly solve the problem of filter membrane clogging.
Using tangential flow filtration to separate EVs
Many documents also point out that when TFF is used to separate EVs, its yield, reproducibility, and decontamination capabilities are superior to the ultracentrifugation method (UC or dUC) called the gold standard for EV purification, and even saves more than 40% of time. , more suitable for large-scale mass production applications.
For a detailed comparison of each method and the EV isolation data of TFF & UC, you can watch the “Exosome Exosome Purification Online Seminar Live Highlights”.
ROCKER Tanfil 100 Tangential Flow Filtration System
◆ Plug & start all-in-one system
◆ Concentration and diafiltration at same run.
◆ Suitable for bioprocesses including DNA and RNA concentration
◆ Easy scale-up. Use same parameters for mass production.
◆ No more membrane fouling, longer lifespan.
◆ CE, RoHS, UKCA certificatedLab scale tangential flow filtration (TFF) system – Tanfil 100
Improve the exosomes isolation efficiency
Although various isolation methods have been developed, these methods still have shortcomings and cannot fully meet the high purity and high yield requirements for isolating exosomes. In order to improve the isolation efficiency and concentration of exosomes, many research teams have begun to try to combine multiple isolation methods; so far, studies have pointed out that multiple isolation methods can increase yield and purity more effectively than a single isolation method.
Exosome Isolation via TFF Using Diverse Technologies
For example, UC and UF are combined to initially extract exosomes, and then IA is used to further purify target exosomes. Alternatively, UC and SEC can be combined to not only process large sample volumes but also effectively reduce interference from contaminants. When selecting a combination method, attention should be paid to whether each single method will cause adverse effects on the target exosomes, such as exosome denaturation and inactivation. The following are exosomes isolation methods using TFF with various technologies.
Target |
EV approach |
TFF function |
Pore size |
Brand name |
Sample source |
|||
Purification |
Concentration |
Buffer |
||||||
1 |
Exosome |
TFF → SEC |
V |
V |
5 nm |
HansaBioMed, TFF-Easy |
Cell culture medium (DP-MSC) |
|
2 |
EVs |
TFF → SEC |
V |
V |
50 ± 10 nm |
HansaBioMed, TFF-EVs |
HPL Supernatant |
|
3 |
Exosome |
UC → TFF |
V |
5 nm |
HansaBioMed, TFF-Easy |
Cell culture medium (NK-92 cell) |
||
4 |
Plant EVs |
dUC → TFF |
V |
5 nm |
HansaBioMed, TFF-Easy |
Cell culture medium (tobacco) |
||
5 |
Exosome |
(TFF) → Qiagen, exoEasy Maxi Kit / SEC |
V (10~20X) |
5 nm |
HansaBioMed, TFF-Easy |
Cell culture medium (cancer cells) |
||
6 |
Exosome |
LSC* (300g) → TFF╳ |
V |
V |
100 kDa |
Pall, Minimate |
Cell culture medium (EF-MSCs) |
|
7 |
EVs |
LSC* (300g) → TFF |
V |
V |
300 kDa |
Pall, Minimate |
Cell culture medium (ASC) |
|
8 |
EVs |
TFF |
V |
V |
V |
0.65 μm, 500 kDa |
Spectrum Labs |
Cell culture medium Lipoaspirate |
*LSC:Low speed centrifugation
Applications of exosomes
- Disease diagnosis/prognosis: used as biomarkers for precision medicine and prediction of disease course, such as Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, autoimmune diseases, neurodegenerative diseases, cancer, etc.
- Disease treatment: molecular drugs, therapeutic agents, drug carriers and delivery for cancer treatment and regenerative medicine and other fields.
- Biological research: DNA, miRNA, etc., to understand the physiological and pathological mechanisms of various diseases.
References:
- A Review of Exosomal Isolation Methods: Is Size Exclusion Chromatography the Best Option, Sidhom et al., International Journal of Molecular Science, 2020
- Biological Functions Driven by mRNAs Carried by Extracellular Vesicles in Cancer, Prieto-Vila et al., Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology, 2021
- Exosome: A Review of Its Classification, Isolation Techniques, Storage, Diagnostic and Targeted Therapy Applications, Zhang et al., International Journal of Nanomedicine, 2020
- Isolation of extracellular vesicles with combined enrichment methods, Stam et al., Journal of Chromatography B, 2021
- Minimal information for studies of extracellular vesicles 2018 (MISEV2018)-a position statement of the International Society for Extracellular Vesicles and update of the MISEV2014 guidelines, Journal of Extracellular Vesicles, 2018
- Multiplexed strategies toward clinical translation of extracellular vesicles, Song et al., Theranostics, 2022
- Progress in Exosome Isolation Techniques, Li et al., Theranostics, 2017
- Review on Strategies and Technologies for Exosome Isolation and Purification, Chen et al., Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology, 2022